The Difference Between a Successful Life and a Meaningful One
The Thought Experiment
Imagine being offered a job that pays $500,000 a year, with just one responsibility:
to sit alone in a windowless room for eight hours a day.
No demands.
No deadlines.
No interaction.
Just passing the time.
Would you take it?
It might sound tempting at first. But I can’t imagine many people lasting very long. Easy money without purpose, challenge, or connection would feel hollow—and fast.
That discomfort is a good place to begin a conversation about the difference between success and meaning.
A Personal Lesson in Success Without Meaning
I once lived a version of that windowless-room job.
A company I was working for was acquired. I knew almost immediately that I didn’t want to be part of the new organization. But they wanted my expertise to help with the transition and integration—and they made the offer hard to refuse: a nine-month role with a generous bonus paid at the end.
The money was enticing, so I agreed.
It didn’t take long to regret it.
I found myself dreading my days, working long hours to build something I wouldn’t be part of once it was finished. Six months in, I was counting down the days. The promised bonus, which had felt so motivating at the start, made no difference at all.
What I felt instead was a quiet, unsettling sense that I was wasting away my days.
Nothing was “wrong.” The arrangement made sense on paper. But the work felt empty—and that emptiness grew louder the longer I stayed.
Success and Meaning Are Not the Same
Experiences like that reveal something we don’t talk about enough: success and meaning are not the same thing.
A successful life is usually measured from the outside—income, status, achievement, recognition.
A meaningful life is experienced from the inside—purpose, contribution, connection, and the sense that what you’re doing matters.
You can have one without the other.
And many people do.
What the Research Tells Us
Research supports this distinction.
Studies led by Roy Baumeister found that happiness and success tend to be associated with comfort, pleasure, and getting what we want, while meaning is more often tied to responsibility, challenge, and giving to others. Meaning doesn’t always feel good in the moment—but it feels worth it when we look back.
The Harvard Study of Adult Development, which has followed participants for more than 80 years, reached a similar conclusion. The strongest predictor of long-term well-being wasn’t wealth or professional success. It was strong relationships—and the feeling of being useful to others.
In short: success optimizes life. Meaning justifies it.
The Question Success Can’t Answer
Success asks, How well am I doing?
Meaning asks, Why am I doing this at all?
You can climb a ladder very successfully and still discover it’s leaning against the wrong wall.
Psychiatrist Viktor Frankl understood this deeply. He observed that people who had a reason to live—someone to care for, work that mattered, or responsibility beyond themselves—were far more resilient in the face of hardship than those focused only on comfort or survival.
Meaning, he argued, comes from contribution, love, and the attitude we choose toward unavoidable difficulty.
A Quieter Measure of a Good Life
Modern life quietly pushes us toward success metrics: productivity, efficiency, growth. These aren’t bad things—but they’re incomplete.
A life optimized only for success can become busy but empty, impressive but unsatisfying.
A meaningful life often looks quieter from the outside. But from the inside, it feels fuller.
Instead of asking only, “Am I succeeding?”
It may be wiser to also ask:
Who benefits from how I’m living?
What feels worth the effort, even when it’s hard?
Would I choose this again, knowing what it costs?
Success can make a life look good.
Meaning makes a life feel worth living.
If you’d like more ideas and inspiration for living life with intention, you can join my free newsletter at the bottom of this page.